Concrete Vs Asphalt: five Things Ghana Must Consider Prior to Making A Choice

Written by Amenorhu kwaku

The Akufo Addo government recently proposed the building of concrete roads rather than the typical asphalt (bitumen) counterpart.


The government in fact purchased the thought of the Ghana Charismatic Bishops’ Conference that proposed that concrete roads carry on more than tarred people in a communique signed by the General Secretary, Rev. Kwesi Deh. The clergy came to this particular conclusion with reference to the Tema Motorway road that had been built many decades still and ago in shape that is good.


The Tema motorway was created during the early 1960’s by Ghana’s very first president, Kwame Nkrumah.


Sticking to the suggestion that pleased the authorities, a comparative analysis was performed to discover the price difference between the 2 kinds of roads. Per the evaluation, Vice President Mahamudu Bawumia disclosed that while a kilometer of asphalt is going to cost $2.8m, that of concrete will set you back $3.8m.


He, nonetheless, clarified the concrete street has a lifetime guarantee of forty years while that of asphalt is ten years, with the realization that concrete albeit becoming costlier to construct, is much more efficient after a while.


Govt To begin with Tema Steel Works Road The proposition to henceforth make use of concrete for road constructions across the nation was effectively shot and endorsed by the box. The Vice President made the disclosure while speaking in the dedication of a temple of Harvest International Ministries (HIM) on Saturday, 15th July 2015.


Based on Dr. Bawumia, the box has chose to carry out the pilot stage of the task together with the Tema Steel Works road.


“We will think about accomplishing this and yes it is going to be transformational because as for installing concrete, we are able to all get it done in Ghana. You do not have to have any individual to come and lay concrete for you. Any mason from any village is able to flock and place the concrete…”


Meanwhile, to help you take a closure on the Concrete vs Asphalt debate, Buzzghana has gathered these really important information which should be considered before selecting between concrete along with asphalt roads.


1. Concrete vs Asphalt – The Differences

Asphalt is a road type finishing composed of aggregates of liquid bitumen, gravel, sand, and stone (coal tar), and that is the oil based glue which keeps everything together. Asphalted roads are normally referred to as tarred roads.


Nearly all asphalt surfaces are laid holding a gravel platform that is typically, as heavy as the asphalt layer, though some’ full depth’ asphalt surfaces are laid on the indigenous sub grade.


On the opposite hand, a concrete road is made using a combination of water, sand, gravel, and cement.


The main distinction between concrete along with asphalt roads stands out as the adhesiveness since both are built of sand and stone. While cement will be the adhesive for concrete roads, bitumen also known as coal tar is utilized in asphalt. If the subgrade is of the identical quality, it’s the completing which produces a distinction between the life span of a street. The underneath parts of the 2 roads are exactly the same with the real difference lying in just the finishing.


2. Road Strength Lies Within

Road construction engineers have discovered the sturdiness of every road mainly lies in the sub grade components of its. This means the extremely held belief that concrete roads are definitely more durable compared to asphalt highways might be misguided as the power and durability of a street rely mostly on how effectively the underneath fortification was completed without always the kind of completing provided to it.


Based on a Civil Engineer who spoke to Citi News on the problem of Ghana’s choice of concrete over asphalted roads, “the concrete roads or maybe the asphalts are just the completed roads. The methodology of any street construction straight from the subgrade on the formation…is in which the meat lies. When you do not compact the sub-base of yours and organic base well, and also you place the concrete on the highway, however extensive it’s, it’ll fail.”


What this means is it’s truly high time the federal government begins looking into who constructs the roads, exactly how well the job is completed at all levels but not sitting to point out concrete is way better or perhaps if not.


3. Construction Cost/Benefits

When comparing the price, concrete roads include a greater paving cost compared to asphalt roads. However, this long as well as extremely held sentiment have been disputed because of the soaring price and limited supply of petroleum products (bitumen) as against limestone lately.


Howbeit, there’s a cost benefit that will come with concrete finishing. This has doing with the reality that laying a concrete requires much less professionalism as neighborhood laborers might be used to do the trick with appropriate supervision, unlike asphalt that involves a lot more knowledge and it is laid using a lot of machines.


The work of local laborers will perform as a way of employment in the nation, thereby yielding household revenue.


4. Maintenance

Both asphalt and concrete driveway cracks might be fixed. Nevertheless, asphalt cracks are simpler to fix in such a manner that they will blend into the initial. Concrete repairs tend to be more apparent on account of weathering, but asphalt may be resurfaced rather cheaply making a fresh top layer in case the existing coating falls into disrepair. This’s improbable for concrete.


In total, the upkeep of concrete roads is much more troublesome than that of asphalt. Based on the Civil Engineer, the fix of concrete takes many weeks and days whereas that of asphalt takes just a couple of times.


Nevertheless, concrete roads don’t involve frequent repair or patching as asphalt roads. It’s really easy for a strongly built concrete road to keep going as much as fifty years with no huge repairs or perhaps sealing. This’s virtually impossible with asphalt.


5. Climate

Severe weather conditions are likely to damage asphalt roads much more than concrete roads. When examining the green elements also the climate change issues, concrete is definitely the smartest choice. Unlike concrete roads, asphalt is recognized to create hydrocarbon contamination to waterways, groundwater, or soil when it’s melted by temperature that is high during or even after construction.


It’s additionally thought that vehicles consume much less gas while jogging on concrete roads. And also this means less contamination of the atmosphere. Nevertheless, concrete roads may not be much too beneficial to the wellbeing of automobiles, along with other things, they tire out tires very easily.


What is the take of yours on this particular issue? Which should Ghana go for: concrete and asphalt? Share the opinion of yours with us in the comment session.

About the author

Amenorhu kwaku